Notes: 2026-11-03 CoreCollective Windows on Arm Technical
Hi all, The notes from this week's call are below. Please let us know if you spot any errors or important omissions. Thanks & regards, Nathalie -- CoreCollective Community Manager Android & WoA working groups *Attended:* Andy Harker, Arm Anthony Roberts, Linaro Don Harbin, CoreCollective Evgeny Karpov, Arm Fathi Boudra, Linaro Gleb Khmyznikov, Microsoft Grant Likely, CoreCollective Jillian Bolton, Arm Marcus Perryman, Microsoft Mayank Agrawal, Qualcomm Nathalie CKC, CoreCollective Omair Javaid, Linaro Pete Brown, Microsoft Saket Jha, Microsoft Stephanie Leong, Arm Thomas Dunkle, Arm Tyler Mullenbach, Arm Varshita Parthasarathy, Arm *Links shared:* - https://github.com/CoreCollective-dev/windows-on-arm-wg/actions/workflows/wh... - https://github.com/CoreCollective-dev/windows-on-arm-wg/issues - https://github.com/actions/runner-images/issues/15052 - https://github.com/arm/gnu-toolchain-for-windows-on-arm64/issues/1 - WoA ARM64 open PRs that need community support <https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DGRCeOySrgqhCqNLBwViQfA01QisUBhZbYlwL7m_4dk/edit?usp=sharing> *AI Notes - please notify us of inaccuracies:* Meeting Overview - Reviewed Python enablement work, focusing on PyArrow ABI3 merge requests, PyTorch wheel availability on PyPI, and automated daily monitoring for broken Windows on Arm packages. - Evaluated compiler and toolchain delivery timelines, including GCC Cygwin target upstreaming to binutils and GCC, native toolchain delivery expectations, LLVM CI staging status, and Git for Windows (MSYS2/MinGit) progress. - Assessed community project dependencies and backlog priorities, reviewing support requirements for GHC and PostgreSQL EDB, and establishing a plan to revalidate and prioritize GCC-blocked items with the steering committee. Decisions/Key Takeaways - Arm confirmed that early native toolchain build bits can't be published directly from Arm due to internal policy restrictions. Also, putting together the bits would be high-effort for someone outside of Arm - better to wait for native toolchain to be published upstream. - GHC maintainers can come to CoreCollective WoA Technical WG for technical guidance. Qualcomm providing hardware donations for GitLab CI. Financial support for GHC maintainers to maintain the GitLab CI would have to be discussed with WoA SC, but current thinking is just HW + tech guidance. - Windows on Arm Working Group meetings are now open to external community participants via calendar invitations available on the CoreCollective WoA WG subpage <https://corecollective.dev/working-groups/windows-on-arm/>. - [Deferred] Prioritization and resource allocation for backlog projects blocked by GCC deferred to the steering committee. Action Items - *Fathi B.* - Address remaining review feedback on the PyArrow ABI3 merge request before handing off the patch set to Microsoft. - *Gleb K.* - Investigate extending the daily package monitor to track library releases dropped by PyPI. - *Marcus P.* - Find out: is R blocked by GCC (what's currently documented), or by CI/CD? - *Mayank A.* - Add the date of last maintainer activity to the blocked PR support tracking sheet <https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DGRCeOySrgqhCqNLBwViQfA01QisUBhZbYlwL7m_4dk/edit?usp=sharing> . - Email Gleb K. the details for PyMuPDF to test tracking dropped releases in the daily monitor. - Contact the third-party maintainer regarding PostgreSQL EDB support. - Coordinate with Gaurav regarding funding mechanisms for PyArrow maintenance ahead of the next call. - Inform Gaurav of Pete trying to use Android Studio in Canary (but it's not) so Gaurav can prepare an update for the next call. - Respond to GHC maintainers to invite them to the CoreCollective WoA working group call (calendar invite can be downloaded at WoA WG page <https://corecollective.dev/working-groups/windows-on-arm/>). - *Nathalie C.* - (DONE) Add the revalidation and prioritization of the GCC-blocked items list and the status of R to the steering committee agenda. - (DONE) Adjust sharing permissions or split the PR support tracking sheet tab into a separate document <https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DGRCeOySrgqhCqNLBwViQfA01QisUBhZbYlwL7m_4dk/edit?usp=sharing> for broader working group access. - *Thomas D.* - Check ComfyUI status on Windows on Arm following updates to torchvision. For Future - Linaro LLVM main upstream build bots to transition to new hardware pending decision from marketing and finance, or face discontinuation in upcoming weeks. Notes - *Python Ecosystem & Wheel Maintenance* - Fathi B. addressed previous review feedback on the PyArrow ABI3 merge requests; the changes are awaiting the next review cycle before handoff to Microsoft. - Microsoft determined that existing funding for PyTorch is sufficient to cover Windows on Arm and is working on resolving missing wheels on PyPI. - Funding channels for PyArrow engineering review time remain under internal review, with Gaurav scheduled to decide on funding allocation. - Gleb K. implemented a daily GitHub Actions monitor scanning package repositories to detect Windows on Arm build failures where AMD64 builds succeed (see links section above): - Identified an MSVC compiler failure in the GitHub runner image affecting h5py. - Identified build issues in SciPy, with recent pull requests currently under test to resolve them. - Agreed to explore monitoring PyPI directly to catch instances where Windows on Arm support is dropped in new library releases, such as PyMuPDF. - *GCC & Native Toolchain Delivery* - Evgeny K. reported that the current priority is upstreaming the Cygwin target to binutils, GCC, MinGW, and Cygwin: - Patches were submitted to binutils, with remaining repository patches planned over the next one to two weeks. - Native toolchain delivery will follow Cygwin upstreaming, targeting availability by the end of the year. - Early publication of downstream native toolchain binaries by Arm was ruled out due to internal policy restrictions and prerequisites like auto-import. - *Git for Windows & MSYS2 Enablement* - Git Bash on Arm64 is performing on par with x86 under cross-compilation testing. - MinGit is buildable from submitted changes currently open in a pull request against the MSYS2 packages repository. - Upstream MSYS2 maintainers have begun reviewing the pull request and creating follow-up pull requests based on the submitted work. - *Backlog Prioritization & Blocked Packages* - Marcus P. initiated an effort to identify and prioritize packages blocked by GCC ahead of native toolchain availability: - Perl was identified as a primary candidate due to extensive GCC dependencies across ecosystem libraries, despite Strawberry Perl having LLVM-based Arm native bits. Once the toolchain is in place, that is something that we can qualify and we can engage on. - R was thought to have an existing community native installer for Windows on Arm, so it is likely unblocked. - ComfyUI was noted as previously blocked by torchvision, but torchvision is now native; status requires retesting. - Krita upstream progress is stalled after maintainers requested a migration to Clang 20 and subsequently became unresponsive. - *LLVM Infrastructure* - Omair J. reported no active Windows on Arm projects currently underway at Linaro. - LLVM upstream CI remains divided, with the staging build bot operating on new hardware while the main build bot runs on legacy hardware. Awaiting Linaro marketing and finance approval to change. - *Community Engagement & Ecosystem Support (PostgreSQL, GHC, Android Studio)* - PostgreSQL BuildFarm and releases are active, but EDB support requires third-party engagement; Mayank A. was provided contact details to follow up. - Qualcomm completed build work for GHC: - Qualcomm agreed to supply Snapdragon devices for GitLab CI to maintainers. - Maintainers will be directed to the working group for technical assistance. - Financial support for GHC maintainers to maintain the GitLab CI would have to be discussed with WoA SC, but current thinking is just HW + tech guidance. - Android Studio Canary not yet having Windows on Arm support; to seek clarification from Gaurav.
participants (1)
-
Nathalie Chan King Choy (Windows on Arm)